The Modern Love Story According to Emily Henry

Beyond tropes: How the author redefines contemporary romance.

How do you define a love story? I find myself asking that question often, especially as the world seems to be losing a shared understanding of it—and as societal changes spark new ways of talking about love. Can these stories still feel relatable, or do they risk becoming disconnected from the lives we actually lead? Do they make us pause and reflect on a particular aspect of our own experiences, or simply offer fleeting comfort?

For a while now, romance novels have been boxed into a narrow image: formulaic, light, and sometimes dismissed as “guilty pleasures.” We hear of labels such as “enemies-to-lovers trope” or “fake-dating trope”, and even plots that, well… aren’t plots, but just descriptions that limit themselves to physical relationships. I myself am extremely picky with this genre, and I want to talk about a writer who is pushing against those stereotypes, and is redefining what an actual love story can look like. I want to talk about the only romance writer I read: Emily Henry.

More than her commercial success, Emily Henry’s romances are not just about the inevitability of two people ending up together; they’re about how love collides with grief, ambition, friendship, and identity. She raises the question of what it means to fall in love when you’re still figuring out who you are (however long that takes), and whether a relationship can be both a sanctuary and a catalyst for growth. Her romances don’t simply chase the thrill of the meet-cute or the comfort of a happy ending, they dig into the messy in-between–the doubts, the insecurities, the fears of vulnerability–that make love both exhilarating and terrifying at the same time. And more importantly: how that is totally okay. That’s the main reason why I love Emily’s style: she bridges the perfect gap between romance and literary fiction, appealing to readers who might never have considered picking up the genre.

Her work also reflects a larger generational shift in romance writing, where other authors are leaning into tropes or escapist fantasies. She completely dismantles the idea that romance has to look one way or serve one type of reader–a reminder that love stories can be just as complex, layered, and vital as any other form of storytelling.

The Anatomy of an Emily Henry Romance

1. Complex, flawed characters

One of Emily Henry’s greatest strengths lies in how she builds her characters. You don’t see any of the archetypal romance heroes and heroines, i.e. perfectly confident men or endlessly charming women. Her protagonists feel recognizably and deeply human. Just like the rest of us, they carry emotional baggage, wrestle with insecurities, and make mistakes. For example, in People We Meet on Vacation (2021), Poppy’s chaotic energy and Alex’s measured restraint aren’t “quirks”; they’re points of tension that reveal the difficulty of reconciling differences in long-term connection. Similarly, in Happy Place (2023), Harriet’s struggle with conflict avoidance captures a VERY real flaw that makes her journey toward love and self-assertion more meaningful, and reassures us that we’re not the only ones, in certain cases. In short, the characters are not idealized–they are vulnerable, layered, and completely relatable.

2. Romance as self-discovery

At the heart of every single one of Henry’s novels is the idea that love is not a replacement for selfhood but a pathway to it. Again, all together: love is not a replacement for selfhood but a pathway to it. Romance is a vehicle for self-discovery, a mirror through which characters (and us) learn who they are and what they need. In Beach Read (2020), January’s exploration of grief and her struggle to reconcile her identity as a romance writer herself mirrors her evolving relationship with Gus to the point; the act of falling in love is inseparable from her journey toward self-acceptance. I think this emphasis sort of reframes the genre’s traditional “love conquers all” narrative into something more nuanced: that love matters most when it deepens, rather than diminishes, one’s sense of self. It should not conquer your sense of self, but make it an ally if we want to stay in the whole “conquering” metaphor.

3. The blending of genres and literary styles

The books themselves (ask them, not me) seem to refuse to be boxed into a single genre. It’s true, they are undeniably romances, but they also carry the cadence and thematic weight of contemporary literary fiction. The prose is sharp, full of vivid imagery and clever banter, while also willing to linger in emotional depth. And we have, ladies and gentlemen, what makes or breaks a story: CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT! like Book Lovers (2022). A kind of meta-romance–it pokes fun at familiar tropes like the “cold career woman” or the “big city vs. small town” clash, but at the same time leans into them with sincerity, giving way to both a playful commentary on the genre and a genuinely heartfelt love story. In this sense, Henry occupies a rare space: her books are accessible enough to feel like “beach reads” but crafted with enough literary texture to invite deeper critical engagement.

4. Tone and voice

Maybe the best relationships are just really good conversations. In any case, that’s what Emily Henry makes me think! A blend of razor-sharp humor, heartfelt vulnerability, and conversational intimacy. Forget the physical aspect for a second, her banter sparkles. It makes the romantic tension palpable, but she also does such a good job of pairing it with moments of raw emotional honesty. It truly and honestly feels like her characters actually LISTEN to each other, and that makes us as readers appreciate the little moments that are evidently basic human interaction. It can be as simple as Miles remembering Daphne’s coffee order in Funny Story (2024), way before their romance begins. The tonal balance that is both entertaining and cathartic is actually such a good foundation to the emotional journey ahead, and is something that makes readers kind of less skeptical of romance.

“All those moments throughout the days, weeks, months that don’t get marked on calendars with hand-drawn stars or little stickers. Those are the moments that make a life. Not grand gestures, but mundane details that, over time, accumulate until you have a home, instead of a house. The things that matter.” — Emily Henry (Funny Story)

These elements create a version of romance that does not settle for escapism alone. Love is not a cure-all just by itself. In Happy Place, for instance, Harriet and Wyn’s story is not about whether they love each other, but about whether they can reconcile the ways they’ve hurt each other—and themselves. Characters (people!) are allowed to be flawed without losing their worthiness of love. In this way, the happy ending feels earned because it emerged from struggle and harsh truths.

BONUS: her stories always center around books in some way! Whether it’s Book Lovers with its literary agents and publishing world, Beach Read featuring two writers navigating creative blocks, or People We Meet on Vacation with its protagonists bonded over shared reading habits, books are more than background—they’re central to character, connection, and conflict.

Why I Keep Coming Back to Emily Henry

When I say that Emily Henry’s books are the only romances I read, it’s not meant as a dismissal of the entire genre–it’s an acknowledgment that her approach captures something I rarely find elsewhere. Personally, I don’t want to read about predictable tropes, characters who feel more like archetypes than people, and plots that seem too polished to belong to real life. I like realistic stories, some that might not always only comfort me, but make me reflect on my own relationship with romance.

Emily Henry’s characters carry flaws that echo my own insecurities and inner conflicts. They’re situations I recognize, and I absolutely love how her portrayals of intimacy go way beyond the physical to capture the idea and the susceptibility of truly being seen. I really think it’s important, in this day and age, to be reminded of the complexity of love in our actual world, where relationships demand the big three: growth, communication, and courage.

And again, the importance of good conversation makes its way to the top. I can’t emphasize how much this reflects the very root of connection between two people: the need and want to be understood, seen, and listened to. The idea that you could love someone just for their presence, that you can appreciate a smile, a gesture, a tic they have. That you can’t change someone–and shouldn’t try to–and what a beautiful thing it is to love someone for exactly who they are while respecting the time and space they need to grow on their own. There’s something deeply beautiful in choosing each other as you are, and continuing to do so as you both change in your own ways.

“Maybe love shouldn’t be built on a foundation of compromises, but maybe it can’t exist without them either. Not the kind that forces two people into shapes they don’t fit in, but the kind that loosens their grips, always leaves room to grow. Compromises that say, there will be a you-shaped space in my heart, and if your shape changes, I will adapt. No matter where we go, our love will stretch out to hold us, and that makes me feel like … like everything will be okay.” — Emily Henry (Book Lovers)

This is not to say that Emily Henry’s stories are heavy-handed or cynical. They still carry the joy, the humor, and the swoon-worthy moments that make romance so beloved. The difference is that those moments never feel unearned once the couple finally comes together, because you see the characters wrestle with everything else along the way. This is another reason why her romances stand apart for me: they offer more than just a distraction or a fantasy. They remind me that love, in its truest form, is never about perfection, but about persistence–the willingness to be known and accepted by another person (not easy!). It’s also kind of why I keep returning to her stories (writing this as I’m re-reading Funny Story).

A Word on the Evolving Face of Romance

The perception of romance as unserious and too “fluffy” in literary criticism stems partly from the genre’s recent history of emphasizing escapism and frankly, unrealistic dramatized stories. With Emily Henry and any other stemming similar works, the tide can and is slightly shifting. I like that there’s a challenge vis-à-vis those assumptions, proving that romance can be artful, reflective, and emotionally-packed (in the right sense of the word). We can start to see diverse cultural perspectives, orientations, and lived experiences to their stories. It doesn’t matter who falls in love with whom, how old they are, what they look like or what they do for a living, what matters is that they do fall in love. As a result, romance today seems to be less a narrow category than a broad spectrum, and offers multiple entry points for different readers.

In terms of realism and reflective-leaning plots, novels like Emily Henry show a crucial thing: that the tension often comes not from outside forces, but from internal struggles that readers recognize from their own lives. The conflict lies between the two people themselves, not in some convenient outside obstacle. It’s up to those who commit to each other to fix anything that might be broken, and in a way, this puts a sense of responsibility and accountability on the table for them and us readers, something I deeply respect and I think deserves more attention.

The genre is still negotiating a delicate balance between escapism and authenticity, and that tension has made romance more scattered–and more dynamic–than it previously did. For some, romance will always be comfort food: stories that affirm love’s joy and possibility. For others, it’s a space to explore identity, power, and vulnerability. Social media and online book communities amplify this variety, as readers debate, recommend, and reshape what they expect from the genre. The result is a richer, more plural understanding of romance—one that defies easy definitions but makes the conversation around it more compelling, and I’m interested to see where it goes from there.

Perhaps the most exciting part of this shift is that it challenges us—as readers and as a culture—to rethink what we value in stories about love. Do we crave comfort and certainty, or do we want narratives that mirror the messiness of our own lives? Can romance be both an escape and a mirror at once? Emily Henry suggests that it can, and that’s what makes her such a vital voice in this moment.

Her novels leave me believing that romance is not just about who we end up with, but about how love shapes us—our choices, our growth, our sense of belonging. And if that is what romance can be, then maybe it’s a genre worth taking seriously after all.

If you’re curious to see what modern romance can truly be, here are Emily Henry’s must-read books to dive into:

Beach Read (2020)

People We Meet on Vacation (2021)

Book Lovers (2022)

Happy Place (2023)

Funny Story (2024)

Great Big Beautiful Life (2025)

My personal favorites being Book Lovers and Funny Story. Check them out here on Goodreads.

(Yes, she has consistently released a book every year since 2020, and we love her for that.)

The Back Rows